• The Met
  • The Art Renewal Center
  • William Bouguereau

  • My Favorite Art
  • Jeune Fille se Defendant Contre L'amour
    by William Bouguereau

  • Le_ravissement de Psyche
    by William Bouguereau

  • Flagellation de Notre Seigneur Jésus Christ
    by William Bouguereau
My Photo
Name:
Location: Liverpool, NY

"In my house, I'm a big deal. That's all that matters."

email

About The Ultra Rev

Facebook


Free Hit Counters

Powered by Blogger

Thursday, September 04, 2008

Quitting Church?

VirtueOnline: Sunday Morning, Staying Home

The linked article is a review of the book Quitting Church by Julia Duin, who claims there are a number of people who are quitting evangelical churches. They long for a decent church but can't find one. Here are some of the reasons she has uncovered:
"She reports, among other things: a lack of a feeling of community among church members, inducing loneliness and boredom; church teaching that fails to go beyond the basics of the faith or to reach members grappling with suffering or unanswered prayer; pastors who are either out of touch with their parishioners or themselves unhappy, or who fail to shepherd their flocks, or who are caught up in scandal, or who try to control the lives of church members in a high-handed way. She claims that many churches have "inefficient leadership models" and that many, preoccupied with the care of families, neglect single people."
A personal observation: when I pastored a church I had numerous clergy friends that were very dissatisfied with their parishes and we talked about the clergy crisis of pastors leaving ministry at alarming rates and churches firing their pastors. For the past 2 years now I have been in a lay person role in the church and now I have numerous friends that talk to me about their disappointment with their current church situation and don't really see other viable, enticing church options. There is a lot of church unhappiness out there at the moment.

Comments on "Quitting Church?"

 

Blogger Dan said ... (5:32 PM, September 04, 2008) : 

So, what's the deal? Just what is it that 'church' is supposed to be? When you talk to either group what is it that would finally 'satisfy' their need, 'lay' or 'clergy'?

Have we bought into the our contemporary consumer culture here in the good ol' USA(assuming that the folks you are conversing with are USAmericans:-0). What I mean by this is, have we created in our minds some "model" of perfection that then becomes the measure of what we expect from a church and leadership? Can anyone or any group live up to the ideal model we carry in our minds? Where did this model come from?

I know, what if those who are experiencing... what do we call it... holy disgruntledness (?) what if they were to plug into a congregation and prayerfully begin to live out the community they are insisting doesn't exist anywhere anymore (if it ever did exist). Perhaps meeting with their leaders and praying with them, showing genuine love toward them... Oh, I don't know!

Hey, how about this, maybe that line for that old 60's or 70's pop song could be applied here-

...if you can't be with the one you love (the perfect pastor, church, church leaders) love the one your with (the disheartened, disappointing, exhausted, distracted...).

Just a thought, and probably not even getting at what Julia and company are really concerned about.

 

Blogger theultrarev said ... (9:20 AM, September 06, 2008) : 

ROTFLMAO. Very funny ... "love the one you're with" ...

There's something seemingly unidentifiable or unknown that's making a lot of people unhappy or disgruntled with their church at the moment.

I think there is such a thing as a holy disgruntledness. We should never really be satisfied with the growth of the church or the number of people accepting Christ, or with our personal or corporate holiness.

But whatever it is that is making the church unhappy at the moment, I'm not sure it's holy.

 

Blogger Dan said ... (5:27 PM, September 06, 2008) : 

Agreeded, we can never be satisfied in the present cosmos but as those who have gone before us we long for...

May I recomend a book? Robert Jenson, A Religion Against Itself. published in 67 I think.

 

post a comment